Merge branch 'improve-council-rules'

1 files changed, 44 insertions, 21 deletions

diff --git a/docs/src/lemmy_council.md b/docs/src/lemmy_council.md
index 46b4c3b1..d5b9c790 100644
--- a/docs/src/lemmy_council.md
+++ b/docs/src/lemmy_council.md
@@ -3,30 +3,52 @@
 - A group of lemmy developers and users that use a well-defined democratic process to steer the project in a positive direction, keep it aligned to community goals, and resolve conflicts. 
 - Council members are also added as administrators to any official Lemmy instances.
 
-## Voting / Decision-Making
+## 1. What gets voted on
 
-### Process
-- Anything is open for discussion
-- Voting done through matrix chat reacts (thumbs up/thumbs down)
-- Require a simple majority for votes. (Maybe 2/3rds for more debated decisions).
-- Once a decision is reached democratically, the decision is binding and all group members have to follow it
-- All members of the Lemmy council have equal voting power.
-- Voting must stay open for at least 2 days.
+This section describes all the aspects of Lemmy where the council has decision making power, namely:
 
-### What gets voted on
-- Membership (joining, removing)
 - Coding direction
   - Priorities / Emphasis
   - Controversial features (For example, an unpopular feature should be removed)
-- Communication mediums
-- Conflict resolution
-- dev.lemmy.ml (domain and server)
-- lemmy.ml and subdomains (excluding communism.lemmy.ml)
-- git repo including mirrors (on github, gitea, etc)
-- Any official accounts of the Lemmy project, for example the Mastodon account or the Liberapay account
+- Moderation and conflict resolution on:
+  - [dev.lemmy.ml](https://dev.lemmy.ml/)
+  - [github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy](https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy)
+  - [yerbamate.dev/LemmyNet/lemmy](https://yerbamate.dev/LemmyNet/lemmy)
+  - [weblate.yerbamate.dev/projects/lemmy/](https://weblate.yerbamate.dev/projects/lemmy/)
+- Technical administration of dev.lemmy.ml
+- Official Lemmy accounts
+  - [Mastodon](https://mastodon.social/@LemmyDev)
+  - [Liberapay](https://liberapay.com/Lemmy/)
+  - [Patreon](https://www.patreon.com/dessalines)
+- Council membership changes
 - Changes to these rules
 
-## Joining
+## 2. Feedback and Activity Reports
+
+Every week, the council should make a thread on Lemmy that details its activity during the past week, be it development, moderation, or anything else mentioned in 1.
+
+At the same time, users can give feedback and suggestions in this thread. This should be taken into account by the council. Council members can call for a vote on any controversial issues, if they can't be resolved by discussion.
+
+## 2. Voting Process
+
+Most of the time, we keep each other up to date through the Matrix chat, and take informal decisions on uncontroversial issues. For example, a user clearly violating the site rules could be banned by a single person, or ideally after discussing it with at least one other member.
+
+If an issue can not be resolved in this way, then any council member can call for a vote, which works in the following way:
+
+- Any council member can call for a vote, on any topic mentioned in 1.
+- This should be used if there is any controversy in the community, or between council members.
+- Before taking any decision, there needs to be a discussion where every council member can
+explain their position.
+- Discussion should be taken with the goal of reaching a compromise that is acceptable for
+everyone.
+- After the discussion, voting is done through Matrix emojis (👍: yes, 👎: no, X: abstain) and must
+stay open for at least two days.
+- All members of the Lemmy council have equal voting power.
+- Decisions should be reached unanimously, or nearly so. If this is not possible, at least
+2/3 of votes must be in favour for the motion to pass.
+- Once a decision is reached in this way, every member needs to abide by it.
+
+## 4. Joining
 - We use the following process: anyone who is active around Lemmy can recommend any other active person to join the council. This has to be approved by a majority of the council.
 - Active users are defined as those who contribute to Lemmy in some way for at least an hour per week on average, doing things like reporting bugs, discussing rules and features, translating, promoting, developing, or doing other things that aim to improve Lemmy as a whole.
   -> people should have joined at least a month ago.
@@ -34,23 +56,24 @@
 - Note: we would like to have a process where community members can elect candidates for the council, but this is not realistic because a single user could easily create multiple accounts and cheat the vote.
 - Limit growth to one new member per month at most.
 
-## Removing members
+## 5. Removing members
 - Inactive members should be removed from the council after a few months of inactivity, and after receiving a notification about this.
 - Members that dont follow binding council decisions should be removed.
 - Any member can be removed in a vote.
 
-## Goals
+## 6. Goals
 - We encourage the membership of groups such as LGBT, religious or ethnic minorities, abuse victims, etc etc, and strive to create a safe space for them to express their opinions. We also support measures to increase participation by the previously mentioned groups.
 - The following are banned, and will always be harshly punished: fascism, abuse, racism, sexism, etc etc, 
 
-## Communication
+## 7. Communication
 - A private Matrix chat for all council members.
 - (Once private communities are done) A private community on dev.lemmy.ml for issues.
 
-## Member List / Contact Info
+## 8. Member List / Contact Info
 General Contact [@LemmyDev Mastodon](https://mastodon.social/@LemmyDev)
 
 - [Dessalines](https://dev.lemmy.ml/u/dessalines)
 - [Nutomic](https://dev.lemmy.ml/u/nutomic)
 - [AgreeableLandscape](https://dev.lemmy.ml/u/AgreeableLandscape)
 - [fruechtchen](https://dev.lemmy.ml/u/fruechtchen)
+- [kixiQu](https://dev.lemmy.ml/u/kixiQu)